DineGuides

Group Dining in Theater District

15 restaurants in Theater District. Part of our New York Group Dining guide.

Tony's Di Napoli
#1Group Dining
6 photos

Tony's Di Napoli

Italian·$$
📍 147 W 43rd St

This Times Square institution serves up classic Italian-American fare in a lively, old-school atmosphere. Portions are famously massive, designed for sharing, and often accompanied by impromptu singing from the staff. It's a place that feels like stepping back in time, offering a boisterous and generous meal.

🍽️94Food
👋85Service
95Vibe
🔊65Noise
💬

The pasta melted in your mouth like butter

💬

Servers were efficient and professional

Ideal for
Groups and family celebrationsTheater-goers before/after showsTourists seeking classic NYC Italian-American
Amor Loco
#2Group Dining
6 photos

Amor Loco

Mexican·$$
📍 134 W 46th St

Amor Loco shines with its vibrant atmosphere and a full bar, making it a versatile spot for dates, groups, and families. Servers like Natalia and Rose are well-regarded for their attentive and friendly service, enhancing the overall dining experience.

🍽️92Food
👋90Service
92Vibe
🔊65Noise
💬

Been here several times each dish fresh delicious

💬

Music was just a little louder

💬

Water had specks of black pebbles

Ideal for
Broadway theater-goers seeking pre/post-show diningGroups and larger parties (staff accommodates well)Diners seeking vibrant, lively atmosphere and cocktails
Carmine's
#3Group Dining

Carmine's

Italian·$$
📍 200 W 44th St

Carmine's serves up enormous, family-style Italian-American platters in the heart of Times Square. This bustling spot is designed for sharing, making it a lively destination for groups and families looking for hearty, classic comfort food.

🍽️90Food
👋85Service
85Vibe
🔊65Noise
💬

Food is great but not excellent, average quality

💬

Server made it feel like the first time

💬

Stepped onto the set of a mafia movie

Ideal for
Groups of 4+ celebrating special occasionsTourists seeking iconic NYC pre-theater mealDiners wanting generous portions and classic ambiance
AperiBar
#4Group Dining
6 photos

AperiBar

Italian·$$

This cozy spot near Times Square offers a relaxed atmosphere perfect for dates, groups, or solo diners. It's a great place to escape the city's hustle with well-executed Italian-inspired dishes and creative cocktails.

🍽️90Food
👋92Service
90Vibe
💬

Perfectly cooked pasta, excellent service

💬

Reasonable prices for the location

Ideal for
Pre-theatre diners seeking quality meal before BroadwayCouples on date nights or anniversariesSolo diners and small groups
The Long Room
#5Group Dining
6 photos

The Long Room

Irish·$
📍 120 W 44th St

This Irish pub near Times Square offers a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of Dublin pubs, complete with a cozy fireplace and live music. It's a versatile spot, equally suited for a casual bite, a lively happy hour, or a relaxed evening catching a game.

🍽️88Food
👋82Service
92Vibe
70Wait
💬

Came in twice this weekend. Service and atmosphere were great

💬

Comfortable and dark, without being difficult to navigate

💬

The restroom was clean and of ample size

Ideal for
Pre/post-Broadway show dining and cocktailsGroups and celebrations (back lounge space)Couples seeking intimate, cozy atmosphere
Red Lobster
#6Group Dining

Red Lobster

Seafood·$$

This Times Square Red Lobster offers a surprisingly calm refuge from the city's chaos, with attentive service that makes guests feel like VIPs. The seafood is fresh and flavorful, complemented by the addictive Cheddar Bay Biscuits.

🍽️80Food
👋95Service
80Vibe
💬

Located right in the middle of New York City's most famous square

💬

Red Lobster is just as good as it has always been

💬

Surprisingly reasonable by New York standards

Ideal for
Tourists seeking iconic NYC seafood experienceGroups/celebrations needing warm service and festive atmosphereCheddar Bay Biscuit enthusiasts
Junior's Restaurant & Bakery
#7Group Dining

Junior's Restaurant & Bakery

American·$$
📍 1515 Broadway

Junior's is a Times Square institution, serving up classic American comfort food with famously generous portions. While the cheesecake is the undisputed star, the menu offers a wide range of diner staples that satisfy a crowd. It's a bustling, family-friendly spot that feels like a quintessential New York experience.

🍽️85Food
👋88Service
85Vibe
💰70Value
💬

Our server, Manuel, was fantastic.

💬

Feels like being in a Pixar movie.

💬

Half a block from Times Square.

Ideal for
Cheesecake lovers and tourists visiting BroadwayQuick breakfast/brunch before or after showsGroups (spacious, can accommodate large parties)
Pasta Lovers
#8Group Dining

Pasta Lovers

Italian·$$
📍 142 W 49th St

This Italian spot in the theatre district offers a lively atmosphere with a full bar, making it versatile for dates, groups, or solo diners. While the pasta dishes are a highlight, some diners note that portion sizes can be small for the price.

🍽️88Food
👋80Service
85Vibe
💰70Value
💬

The flavor IS AMAZING!!! Please do not change anything

💬

Unfortunately, the second time the pizza was burned

💬

Located right next to Times Square

Ideal for
Tourists visiting Times Square areaGroup dinners with good service luckDiners who prioritize food quality over speed
Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.
#9Group Dining

Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.

American·$$
📍 1501 Broadway

This Times Square institution leans heavily into its Forrest Gump theme, offering a lively, casual atmosphere that's a hit with families. While the vibrant decor and attentive service are consistent draws, the food quality can be hit or miss, with some finding it bland and others enjoying classic seafood dishes.

🍽️78Food
👋88Service
92Vibe
💰68Value
Ideal for
Forrest Gump fans and movie enthusiastsTourists seeking Times Square novelty experiencesGroup celebrations with reliable atmosphere
Connolly's
#10Group Dining

Connolly's

Irish·$
📍 121 W 45th St

Connolly's is a lively, multi-floor Irish pub that feels like a slice of Dublin in the heart of Manhattan. It's a go-to spot for a casual pint and hearty fare, with a rooftop bar offering a unique urban perch. The atmosphere buzzes with live sports and friendly chatter, making it a welcoming spot for groups, families, and solo travelers alike.

🍽️85Food
👋65Service
92Vibe
💬

The best Fish & Chips I've had in NYC

💬

Different staff and different dishes, all fantastic

💬

Prices are very good for the middle of Manhattan

Ideal for
Pre-theater dining and cocktailsTourists seeking authentic Irish pub experienceCasual groups and celebrations
Lagos Tsq
#11Group Dining
5 photos

Lagos Tsq

African·$$$
📍 727 7th Ave

This Times Square spot pulses with Afrobeats and a vibrant energy, transforming into a club after 9pm. It's a place that prioritizes atmosphere, offering a lively scene with a full bar and multiple floors for dancing and socializing.

🍽️85Food
👋70Service
95Vibe
🛡️65Safety
💬

Located in the heart of Times Square, parking is hard to find

💬

Service was quick, even the bar attentive and friendly

💬

Extremely pricey for the taste and portion of the main entrees

Ideal for
Nightlife and celebration eventsGroup dining with music/dance energyTourists seeking Times Square experience
The Perfect Pint
#12Group Dining

The Perfect Pint

Irish·$
📍 123 W 45th St

This Irish pub offers a lively atmosphere with a full bar and multiple levels, including a rooftop. It's a casual spot perfect for groups or a relaxed night out, serving up classic pub fare alongside a wide beer selection.

🍽️80Food
👋70Service
90Vibe
🔊65Noise
💬

We always order the Sheppard pie

💬

Not very expensive according to the location

Ideal for
Tourists seeking iconic Irish pub experienceGroups looking for rooftop drinks and casual foodBeer enthusiasts exploring Irish imports
Duke Eatery
#13Group Dining

Duke Eatery

Mixed/Fusion·$$

Duke Eatery offers a vast array of prepared foods, from a popular salad bar to Korean specialties in the basement. It's a bustling spot perfect for commuters and groups needing quick, diverse meal options.

🍽️80Food
👋85Service
85Vibe
💰60Value
💬

Wish I found this place sooner vs. new rendition is worse

💬

Very convenient when trying to find something quick

💬

Service is very efficient, order machines and payment

Ideal for
Midtown commuters seeking quick lunchKorean food enthusiastsGroup dining with varied tastes
Via Brasil NYC
#14Group Dining
6 photos

Via Brasil NYC

Brazilian·$$
📍 34 W 46th St

Via Brasil NYC brings the vibrant energy of Brazil to the heart of the city, offering a lively atmosphere with live music on weekends. It's a place where authentic flavors meet a welcoming, casual vibe, making it suitable for everything from a casual weeknight dinner to a lively group celebration.

🍽️82Food
👋62Service
88Vibe
Ideal for
Brazilian expats or enthusiasts seeking authenticityTheater-goers near Times Square wanting upscale diningGroups comfortable with elegant, music-enhanced atmosphere
Teriyaki R Us
#15Group Dining

Teriyaki R Us

Japanese·$
📍 150 W 49th St

This fast-casual spot near Times Square offers generous portions of teriyaki dishes. It's a no-frills joint that can be a good option for a quick, filling meal, especially if you're looking for vegetarian choices.

🍽️75Food
👋65Service
75Vibe
💬

Bathroom there did not look like it had been maintained

Ideal for
Quick lunch on business tripGroups seeking shareable portionsChicken teriyaki lovers