DineGuides

Cheap Eats in Theater District

10 restaurants in Theater District. Part of our New York Cheap Eats guide.

Moe Eats NYC
#1Cheap Eats
6 photos

Moe Eats NYC

Halal·$$
📍 120 W 49th St

This halal food truck is a favorite, serving up generous portions of incredibly flavorful chicken and lamb over rice. Moe and his team are known for their excellent hospitality, making every customer feel welcome. It's a go-to spot for delicious, high-quality street food that consistently hits the spot.

🍽️98Food
💰95Value
👋96Service
📍75Location
💬

No upselling or trying to take advantage

💬

His truck also was super clean

Ideal for
Midtown office workers seeking quality lunch valueNYC visitors wanting authentic street halal foodDiners prioritizing fresh ingredients and generous portions
Mama Halal Food
#2Cheap Eats

Mama Halal Food

Halal·$

This halal cart is a standout in a city full of options, rivaling even sit-down Indian restaurants with its remarkably juicy, tikka-spiced chicken. The lamb is tender and flavorful, and the sauces, especially the spicy option, add a perfect kick.

🍽️95Food
💰90Value
👋90Service
🛡️65Safety
💬

No line, didn't have to wait long

Ideal for
Quick halal lunch near Times SquareDiners seeking fresh, well-seasoned street foodBudget-conscious NYC food lovers
Margon
#3Cheap Eats
5 photos

Margon

Cuban·$$
📍 136 W 46th St

This Midtown Cuban spot is a true hole-in-the-wall, serving up authentic flavors with a warmth that makes you feel like family. It's a local favorite for a reason, offering delicious, home-style cooking at prices that respect your wallet.

🍽️95Food
💰90Value
👋95Service
75Wait
💬

Best Cuban restaurant we tried in New York

💬

I was transported to Cuba. It was fantastic

💬

Generous & delicious portions and the staff are so kind

Ideal for
Locals and office workers seeking authentic lunchCuban food enthusiasts visiting NYCTheater-goers needing quick pre-show meal
Tony's Di Napoli
#4Cheap Eats
6 photos

Tony's Di Napoli

Italian·$$
📍 147 W 43rd St

This Times Square institution serves up classic Italian-American fare in a lively, old-school atmosphere. Portions are famously massive, designed for sharing, and often accompanied by impromptu singing from the staff. It's a place that feels like stepping back in time, offering a boisterous and generous meal.

🍽️94Food
💰92Value
👋85Service
🔊65Noise
💬

The pasta melted in your mouth like butter

💬

Servers were efficient and professional

Ideal for
Groups and family celebrationsTheater-goers before/after showsTourists seeking classic NYC Italian-American
Lil Zeus Food Truck
#5Cheap Eats
5 photos

Lil Zeus Food Truck

Greek·$$
📍 112 W 50th St

This Greek food truck serves up authentic flavors with generous portions at wallet-friendly prices. It's a go-to spot for delicious, high-quality meals that rival sit-down restaurants, all served with a friendly, family-like atmosphere.

🍽️92Food
💰90Value
👋90Service
🛡️65Safety
💬

The lamb is probably the best I've ever had

💬

Jerry and Vasilios continue to impress

💬

Great quality and quantity for 9 bucks

Ideal for
Midtown lunch seekers with 25+ min bufferLamb/pork souvlaki enthusiastsValue-conscious diners
Saar Indian Cuisine & Bar
#6Cheap Eats

Saar Indian Cuisine & Bar

Indian·$$
📍 241 W 51st St

This Indian restaurant offers a vibrant taste of North and South Indian cuisine, with a particular knack for balancing authentic flavors with a modern flair. It's a place where attentive service, a warm atmosphere, and well-executed dishes come together, making it a reliable choice for various occasions.

🍽️92Food
💰85Value
👋90Service
💬

Walkable distance to Times Square

💬

Pricing was reasonable for being in the theater district

💬

A loud party of 15 men behind us

Ideal for
Theater district pre-show diningSpecial occasions and celebrationsHappy hour cocktail enthusiasts
AperiBar
#7Cheap Eats
6 photos

AperiBar

Italian·$$

This cozy spot near Times Square offers a relaxed atmosphere perfect for dates, groups, or solo diners. It's a great place to escape the city's hustle with well-executed Italian-inspired dishes and creative cocktails.

🍽️90Food
💰85Value
👋92Service
💬

Perfectly cooked pasta, excellent service

💬

Reasonable prices for the location

Ideal for
Pre-theatre diners seeking quality meal before BroadwayCouples on date nights or anniversariesSolo diners and small groups
Russian Vodka Room
#8Cheap Eats
5 photos

Russian Vodka Room

Eastern European·$$
📍 265 W 52nd St

This cozy Hell's Kitchen spot transports you with its authentic Russian charm and an impressive selection of house-infused vodkas. Live music and a warm, welcoming atmosphere make it a perfect escape for a lively night out.

🍽️90Food
💰85Value
👋85Service
💬

The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, and full of authentic flavors.

💬

The music is a little loud but still enjoyable

💬

Good deal on drinks during Happy Hour

Ideal for
Pre/post-Broadway dinner datesVodka enthusiasts seeking infusionsRepeat diners seeking authenticity
Carmine's
#9Cheap Eats

Carmine's

Italian·$$
📍 200 W 44th St

Carmine's serves up enormous, family-style Italian-American platters in the heart of Times Square. This bustling spot is designed for sharing, making it a lively destination for groups and families looking for hearty, classic comfort food.

🍽️90Food
💰85Value
👋85Service
🔊65Noise
💬

Food is great but not excellent, average quality

💬

Server made it feel like the first time

💬

Stepped onto the set of a mafia movie

Ideal for
Groups of 4+ celebrating special occasionsTourists seeking iconic NYC pre-theater mealDiners wanting generous portions and classic ambiance
Connolly's
#10Cheap Eats

Connolly's

Irish·$
📍 121 W 45th St

Connolly's is a lively, multi-floor Irish pub that feels like a slice of Dublin in the heart of Manhattan. It's a go-to spot for a casual pint and hearty fare, with a rooftop bar offering a unique urban perch. The atmosphere buzzes with live sports and friendly chatter, making it a welcoming spot for groups, families, and solo travelers alike.

🍽️85Food
💰85Value
👋65Service
💬

The best Fish & Chips I've had in NYC

💬

Different staff and different dishes, all fantastic

💬

Prices are very good for the middle of Manhattan

Ideal for
Pre-theater dining and cocktailsTourists seeking authentic Irish pub experienceCasual groups and celebrations