Auberge du Pommier is a long-established fine dining French restaurant renowned for excellent service and romantic ambiance, particularly on the patio. Execution remains polished and staff training is outstanding. However, recent reviews (past 6 months) document a material shift: new ownership/management has introduced a new chef, smaller portions, and less refined flavor profiles. While the restaurant still delivers elegant presentations and warm hospitality, food quality is now inconsistent and increasingly described as bland or unbalanced compared to its pre-2023 reputation.
Execution is generally strong with signature dishes (duck, foie gras, steak, tartare) well-regarded. However, recent reports indicate quality decline under new management—bland seasoning, unbalanced flavors, overcooked fish, and small portions appear in multiple. Sommelier-driven wine program and classical French technique remain reliable.
“New chef, new prices, new portion sizes”
Service is a clear strength. Staff training is outstanding, with multiple named servers (Chad, Andrew, Walter, Elliot, Yanek) well-regarded for attentiveness, knowledge, and genuine warmth. Service remains consistent across visits. One isolated rude interaction from 2 years ago is outlier.
“Attentive without being over the top”
Romantic, elegant French countryside atmosphere with rustic charm. Patio in warm months is standout feature (described as garden in Provence). Fireplace, soft lighting, and separate function rooms create intimate settings. Not pretentious despite fine dining status. Well-regarded as perfect for celebrations.
“Felt like you were in a French patio garden”
Fine dining pricing ($75–$250+ per person depending on menu tier). Regular à la carte menu is expensive; Summerlicious and Winterlicious prix-fixe menus offer better value but receive mixed reception on food quality. Recent reports of smaller portions for same or higher pricing drive down value perception. Wine program is well-regarded but pricey.
“Only way we could swing a three-course meal”